Small Change Budget
The Why? CurveOctober 31, 2026x
230
42:0938.6 MB

Small Change Budget

The first UK budget under Andy Burnham was, by most accounts, pretty underwhelming. So is all the big stuff being kicked into next year in the hope of better times? Or are the problems of huge and expensive government debt, and a weighty benefits bill, plus stagnant household incomes, simply unmanageable for a Labour administration? Phil and Roger ask Paul Johnson, former director of the Institute of Fiscal Studies, now Provost of The Queen’s College, Oxford, and senior adviser at Frontier Economics.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

[00:00:00] The Why Curve, with Phil Dobbie and Roger Hearing. A small budget. A micro budget. Too little. Not one that matches the challenges of our turbulent times. Or one that signalled stability to the markets. Or a budget that kicked all the difficult stuff into next year, in the hope of better times. And after the speech, the criticism and the analysis. Did all this do anything to foster growth? Or ease the pressure on those for whom income does not keep up with everyday expenses. The Why Curve.

[00:00:30] Well, it is very difficult, isn't it? Because Britain has never got over COVID, I think, is the big problem. And so still carrying all this debt. And then you've got the Bank of England that is trying to offload all of its bonds rather too quickly. Faster than most other central banks as well. Which is making the situation even more difficult. Because there's a lot of government bonds out there in the market that nobody really wants very much. And so that pushes the bond yields up, which makes debt very expensive.

[00:00:58] I mean, they are fighting against an awful lot, really. Yeah. And also, of course, you've also got, don't forget, you said from COVID. But we have the 2010 financial crisis, 2008-2010 financial crisis. And many people think things have never looked good since then. Well, absolutely. Absolutely. And yes, because earnings went backwards. You know, the real incomes went backwards over there since then. So, and the answer doesn't seem to be austerity.

[00:01:26] But then Britain's in the situation where it almost has to because everything is so expensive. So, the two things that the UK, I think, is fighting against, and we can talk about this today. Number one is energy is just so expensive in the UK. So, it's got that disadvantage against most of the rest of the world that to get any progress, any productivity growth costs more. Because the base cost, obviously, for everything is energy.

[00:01:50] And then secondly, there's a whole load of people just signing up on sickness benefit in the UK, which is out of proportion with anywhere in the world, just about. So, yeah, yeah, yeah. But, I mean, it's interesting. Some of the data on this, and we're going to hear from our guest in a moment. But the fact is, you know, yes, the bill has gone up, the bill for welfare. But only, you know, it's a very small percentage of overall GDP. You know, there are bigger headwinds than that, really. I mean, people focus on that. But there's a lot more going on.

[00:02:19] And energy price is expensive for everyone. Yeah, but they're more for the UK. I mean, so, you know, I mean, Australia, obviously, Australia produces its own energy. So, it does pay less. And, I mean, it's a problem for the whole of Europe. But Europe, the UK seems to have it worse. Having said that, I've just been landed with an enormous energy bill here, which I just got on and discovered. Actually, I could save 30% if I just switch provider. Ah, well, I think we know what you'll be doing after this podcast.

[00:02:48] After this podcast, yeah. But, yeah, interestingly, the IFS, the International Fiscal Studies, said that this decade is going to be the worst for household incomes in terms of the way people can live their lives and cost of living and everything else. And we've actually got the man who was head of the IFS before, a couple of years ago, now Provost of the Queen's College, Oxford, and Senior Advisor at Frontier Economics. Let's hear what he's got to say about all this. Paul Whiteley.

[00:03:15] So, Paul, the biggest problem is obviously just the amount of debt, isn't it? And once you get into that situation, it's difficult to get out of it because you're paying for that debt. You're trying to cover all your costs, you know, associated with the government running the economy and trying to get growth. But you're fighting against what's happened in the past. And that's a bit of a killer cycle, isn't it? Well, you've hit the nail pretty much on the head, rather, sadly. Short podcast this week.

[00:03:47] That's pretty much what's happening. It's a combination of several things associated with the debt. Obviously, we've got a very big pile of debt, which is something like a trillion pounds now, about 95% of national income. And that's come with, of course, these very dramatic increases in the interest rates on that debt that we've experienced over the last six or seven years.

[00:04:13] So, that huge debt wasn't too much of a problem back in 2019 when interest rates were very low. But interest rates have gone up so much, particularly high levels on UK debt, that we're now spending well north of £100 billion every single year just on servicing the debt. And if you look at the OBR's forecasts, that's going to rise towards £150 billion a year by the end of the decade. And that's money we just have to pay.

[00:04:43] So, it's a combination of the level of debt, the interest on the debt, and actually, to some extent, the kind of debt that we have. So, a lot of it's still held by the Bank of England. We have to pay full Bank of England base rate on that debt immediately. So, obviously, if we took out debt in 2019 at very low interest rates, we'd continue to pay those low interest rates until the debt matures. But if the Bank of England bought the debt, we'd pay the full Bank of England base rate.

[00:05:11] And we've got a lot of index-linked debt. In other words, we pay inflation plus. And obviously, inflation's been quite high. So, we've got too much debt. We've got interest rates that are too high. And arguably, we've got too much of the wrong kind of debt as well. So, I was talking to someone this last week who was making just that point about the fact that the UK has issued so many index-linked bonds, which, in retrospect, was perhaps a mistake. Because I guess when they were issued, it was a time when they thought, well, inflation's not a problem.

[00:05:40] And now, all of a sudden, it is. It's an interesting question. I don't think it was a mistake. I mean, you can look back with hindsight and think, well, maybe that was a mistake. But actually, we were able, at the time, to offer them at very good rates. We had a huge number of institutions desperate to buy them, in particular, our defined benefit occupational pension sector. And there's nothing that the market provides which provides you that kind of protection against debt. So, yes, the state was taking on liabilities.

[00:06:10] But it was doing quite a good job in helping out, essentially, in meeting the demand in the private sector that couldn't be met in any other way. But we're paying for it now because inflation's so much higher. We are paying for it now. Of course, the consequence of all this money going on on debt interest is that we've had these very, very big increases in tax over the last few years.

[00:06:38] And people aren't getting anything back because a lot of it, about half that increase in tax has just gone straight out the window again in paying for higher, paying for those higher debt payments, rather than on the things that people want, like hospitals and pensions and schools and all those kind of things. Paul, you'll be aware that one of the arguments, certainly on the left, is that essentially debt is not as big a problem as people say. Because the government, in the end, is a very solid bet for any kind of investment.

[00:07:08] And yes, at the moment, there is a crisis in international debt, sovereign debt. But actually, longer term, we need to worry less about that, perhaps just print more money, whatever it is. But the main thing is to get the economy going and also to help people out of poverty. And that those should be the priorities. There's a certain sense to that, particularly, you just imagine, from a Labour government. There's absolutely no sense to that. I mean, that really scares me, that kind of view of the world.

[00:07:38] The idea that we can print money in a world in which our inflation rate has been above target constantly for something like the last five years, in a world in which we do need people to lend us money, in a world in which people are really concerned about inflation for obvious reasons, is just for the birds. And the idea that we don't need to worry about our debt, I think, has been proven entirely wrong by recent events.

[00:08:05] Lots and lots and lots of people were saying through the 2010s, and it was much more credible at the time, that we could have been borrowing more to avoid austerity and so on at the time. But actually, the consequence of the amount that we were borrowing over that time and through COVID and so on, and we clearly needed to do that borrowing, we are feeling at the moment, exactly as we've just discussed, the cost of servicing that debt is crowding out all sorts of other things.

[00:08:30] So I absolutely refute the idea that either that we shouldn't worry about it, and in particular, these people who say we can simply print money, you only need to look around the world through history to see the catastrophic consequences that have occurred in countries that have tried to do that. Well, here's another crazy idea for the birds. Let's get these out of the way early on then, the crazy ideas. If we're facing this debt issue and it's faced all over the world,

[00:08:58] because I think almost everyone's facing in different levels, I mean, we've got it worse than most perhaps, but everyone in different levels, perhaps since COVID or since the global financial crisis, are struggling with the fact they're just carrying so much debt. Why doesn't everyone in the world just say, well, you know, it's only money. Why don't we almost start again? Why don't we just set a level at which we can all collectively write off this debt so that we are not hamstrung by holding so much of this money that we're having to pay off? Theo, there's another crazy idea for the birds for you.

[00:09:29] It really is a crazy idea for the birds. I mean, that would create a global economic and financial crisis, the like of which we haven't seen in a century. I mean, people, I mean, the debt is an asset. For what reason, why don't we explain? Yeah, explain. Right, OK. Yeah, yeah. Because the people holding the bonds would lose. Yeah, yeah. The debt is an asset in the hands of people. So if you were to write off our £3 trillion of debt, that would be basically stealing £3 trillion from pension funds,

[00:09:58] from people's pensions, from financial institutions and so on. If you did that, I mean, you know, you'd look at the financial crisis and think it was a picnic. I mean, I'm scared that you've even said it because it's sending a shiver down my spine. He says lots of scary things, I'm afraid. But I can. Yes, indeed. Well, shivers and worries about solutions. But, Paul, the point is we've got a problem, clearly, a massive problem in terms of debt repayment.

[00:10:26] It's not just Britain, but it is Britain to a large extent. And a great need to rejuvenate the economy in some ways, to also get people out of poverty. I mean, are there any solutions? Or is it a doom loop, essentially? We just keep paying more and more and more for debt, and we can't boost the economy or lift people out of difficult times. But you made an important point there as well, Paul, because some people are doing quite well out of this. If you hold the bonds and you're getting a high interest on those bonds, you're doing all right. You've got, you're saying, well, this, you know,

[00:10:55] this doesn't bother me, I'm holding these bonds, they're paying a good return for me. Happy days. Look at the yields I'm getting. Yeah, I mean, there's lots in that. Let's take that first question. I mean, you're right. I mean, one of the consequences of what's happened over the last four or five years is that our occupational pension funds, which for a long time were in real trouble and companies were pouring huge amounts of money into them, are now in surplus. And actually, companies are not having to put money into them. And there are certainly arguments about

[00:11:25] whether they should be able to take some of that surplus. So there have been beneficiaries in that sense. And the interest in general that people can get on their savings and the interest in government debt and the interest you get in your savings are fairly closely related, have clearly gone up. And there's a downside as well, of course, which is the interest rates in general are higher. So people who with mortgages and so on are having to pay some back. So there are definitely winners and losers from a higher interest rate environment,

[00:11:55] as there were winners and losers from the low interest rate environment we had in the 2010s. So people with mortgages did incredibly well through the 2010s and had much higher disposable income than they might otherwise have expected. So yes, there are definitely winners and losers from this. In terms of the problems that we face, the first thing I'd say is it's not specifically actually a UK problem. And we have somewhat higher interest rates than we're facing than other governments.

[00:12:24] But actually, our debt is about average by G7 standards. It's high by border advanced economy standards. Not as high as France, for example. It's not quite as high as France, but our interest rates are still higher than the French extraordinarily. I mean, partly, I think, reflecting our very poor performance on controlling inflation over a long period of time. And the fact that I think markets still see us as a fairly risky bet, even when comparing us with France.

[00:12:53] But broadly, this is a fairly broad-spread international issue. I mean, can we do anything about it? The answer is yes, but we continually choose not to. So, I mean, there's one thing that really took my eye in the... Just as one example took my eye in the Office of Budget Responsibility report that went alongside the budget on Wednesday, where they look at house building.

[00:13:22] And house building is... If there's one thing that you would have taken from the 2024 Labour government, that you really think they would have done everything they could to have done something about this house building. They're absolutely clear. Commitments of 1.5 million new homes over the period of the Parliament. And they talked about it a lot, a lot, a lot. And that was the right thing to do. And they've simply made things worse. I mean, they have decided to increase regulation. They have decided to increase costs. And that's layered on top of the increased regulation

[00:13:52] and costs created by the previous government. And the result has been a collapse in house building. Now, that is just a choice. That's a political choice. And the choice has been to make ourselves poorer rather than to deal with some of the underlying problems. And I could give you dozens of examples of this. Well, so do you think that's a key part then, just UK bureaucracy? Because it is pretty bad, isn't it? Across all sections of the UK economy,

[00:14:21] it seems like we are overgoverned. It's a real problem. We know that it's more expensive to build pretty much anything here than pretty much anywhere else in the world. I mean, the nuclear power stations we're building at the moment are the most expensive nuclear power stations ever built anywhere in the world. Building the sort of the bureaucracy around the Lower Thames Crossing. I can't remember. There's some extraordinary number, like hundreds of thousands of pages of reports have to be put together before they could even start.

[00:14:52] And I think we've already spent more on it before it's even started to be built than the entire cost of building similar things in some other countries. And we've saved bats by not building HS2. If you look at that, an HS2 makes me absolutely boil with fury. I mean, we're spending, the Department of Transport this year is spending more on HS2 than its entire rest of the rail network. It's spending more on HS2, it's spending twice as much on HS2

[00:15:20] than the entire National Highways network. I mean, this is absolutely insane. And at the same time, we have many of our biggest cities in the north which don't have anything approaching a decent mass transit system. We have dreadful railway connections across much of the country. And we're pouring money down the drain on HS2,

[00:15:46] on bat tunnels, on fish discos, and so on and so on. So yes, I really do... I haven't heard about it. You have to tell me. How can't you let go out of that slide? I haven't heard about it. It's an Oxford thing, I think, fish discos, I gather. I don't know. No, no, not a Oxford thing. Something that goes on? No, no. This is putting noise-creating things by nuclear power stations to ward off fish who might otherwise wander

[00:16:15] into the excessively warm water created by the power stations at very big cost and at incredibly small benefit in terms of the fish safe. So the fish discos go alongside the bat tunnels as an example of how we managed to chuck enormous amounts of money away for very little benefit. But, Paul, I mean, every government that comes in and talks about a bonfire of red tape, and very often, as you say, it doesn't do it. But the whole problem can't be just down to regulation

[00:16:44] and red tape and incompetence. I mean, there must be something more significant than that that's holding back the economy. I mean, is it, you know, let's focus on the elephant in the room, which everyone has been talking about since the budget, which is the benefits bill. I mean, is that a massive drag on the economy? Is that something the government needs to sort out? I mean, what's the real truth on that? Because the mental health issue in the UK is outside the norm for developed nations globally, I think.

[00:17:14] It depends how you look at this. If you just look at the overall spending on benefits, pensions and benefits of working age, they have been on a very slight upward trend for the last 40 years. We're actually spending less now, always a fraction of national income on these benefits than we were in 2010.

[00:17:39] And they are rising a bit in total over this decade, but a significant amount. By getting on from 1% of national income, that's quite a big chunk. But it's not, you know, it's not sort of at the scale of the rate of increase that you might expect from some of what you hear. Now, all of that said, there are elements of it which are clearly problematic. And if you look at where the increases are coming from, they're largely coming at the moment

[00:18:06] from increases in benefits paid to people with health problems. So the disability benefits, personal independence payment, and the incapacity benefit element of universal credit. Now, spending on those is rising by tens of billions of pounds over this decade, as the numbers of people claiming the benefits is going on very fast indeed. So there's clearly a problem there. And personal independence payment in particular is clearly doing things and paying money to people

[00:18:37] for whom it was not originally designed. And we clearly need to get, we clearly need to get a handle on that. There are all sorts of other problems with the benefits. And in particular, the Department of Work and Pensions, if someone claims a benefit and they are deemed eligible, they just get the money. And the Treasury will give the Department of Work and Pensions whatever money it needs for that. But if they want to spend money

[00:19:05] on sort of controlling that budget, on helping people into work, on making it more effective, then they've got a very limited budget on that. I can't remember the exact numbers, but I think they spend something like 25 times as much on actually giving benefits to people as they do on helping people. So that is potentially something one could do something about. And there are all sorts of examples of situations in which the system isn't working. But I think that...

[00:19:34] But would it make much difference, Paul? Would it actually change things? Because as you said, it's relatively... I mean, it's 1%, which is something, but, you know. So that's partly my point. Now, is that what's driving our current fiscal problems? No. It's not very different to how it's been for a very long time. Is it something that we could make a lot better and would be good for the people involved and would do some good for the budget? Yes. So I think we need to kind of distinguish those two things.

[00:20:03] You're not going to solve all of our problems by any means by overhauling the working age benefit system, but you should nevertheless put quite a lot of effort into it, and in particular, in making more sense of the disability benefit system because we are spending money we almost certainly shouldn't be spending and it's probably not good for the people involved in the long term. So it's been described as a flotilla of small measures. It's very hard, mind you, to do big measures

[00:20:31] when you haven't been through an election yourself, so you're still working on someone else's mandate in a way. But we do need big measures, don't we? We need radical changes. We need tax reform. We need incentives for people to work more. I wonder whether, in fact, the incentive to work more is that if you work more, you get some tax benefits to save better, for example, in a way that you couldn't do if you weren't earning that income in the first place. So all of that needs to be looked at holistically, and it hasn't been forever.

[00:21:00] However, so is there a way that, you know, resolution could be found to a lot of these problems if we just change the tax system? Well, we certainly need to change the tax system. It's not, I mean, for two reasons. First of all, as I mentioned earlier, we are raising more tax than ever before, and taxes are rising very, very fast over this decade. I mean, I don't think people quite understand the extent to which we have just phenomenally increased taxes

[00:21:28] over the 2020s in a way that we have never done before in peacetime by 5% or 6% of national incomes. That's by way more than £150 billion a year. This is a huge increase in tax. And, of course, the more you collect in tax, the more important it is to get the tax system right. Now, it's a particularly difficult time to do that, though, because alongside that, we've got almost no increase in income.

[00:21:55] So we're going a decade, a whole decade, essentially, without our incomes growing at all. Now, that's just, that's probably the worst decade in, you know, a century or possibly in two centuries. I mean, that's the scale of how dreadful the lack of increase in living standards is over this decade. And, of course, if people aren't getting any better off, then any tax reform, which leaves some people worse off and some people better off, it's really hard to achieve because anyone who's left worse off is going to be really very unhappy about it.

[00:22:23] All of that said, you're right, it is clearly something we need to do. We don't have a tax system that's fit for purpose and we haven't had any kind of fundamental overhaul of it, arguably, since the 1980s, when there was lots and lots of money around and that gave Nigel Lawson the opportunity to do some significant tax reform. But we've essentially had nothing since. So Roger's going to go, oh, God, here he goes again, so everything seems to work better in Australia. But the way pensions are dealt with in Australia

[00:22:51] is fundamentally different to the way it is in the UK. And I do think this does work better. So here you pay 15% tax as you take the money out. And then when you claim it, when it gets paid out in your retirement, it's tax-free. So it's as opposed to getting taxed based on, which means there's an incentive for you to put more and more money, basically, into your pension scheme. Consequently, this country's got

[00:23:18] one of the largest superannuation funds per person. Let me stop you there. I think that's not right. The main reason, I mean, the only reason that Australia has such big superannuation funds is it's compulsory. I mean, you just have to put 15% in. Well, that too. And actually, the tax system there is much more complicated than the tax system here. I mean, we've got a big tax incentive here. I mean, you put your money in entirely free. Of income tax. And indeed, free of national insurance contributions.

[00:23:48] And you can take a quarter of it out. Yeah. Completely free of income tax. The tax incentives here are really very substantial. And I think they're bigger here than they are in Australia. The difference is that you are compelled to put a very large amount of money in Australia. Thank you, Paul. I think we've established that things are not necessarily that much better in Australia. No, but the upshot of it is, which was the second point I was trying to get to, means that there's a lot more money swilling around in these pension funds looking for homes,

[00:24:18] looking for investments. And you'd assume if investments are made and they're made domestically, then that would add to growth for the economy. Well, again, again, again, again, again, the issue here is not about the amount of money in our pension funds. The thing is that only 5% of the money on our pension funds is invested domestically. Most of it in the sort of fine contribution, personal type pensions, automatic enrollment type pensions,

[00:24:47] almost all of that is invested in global trackers, which is actually from an individual perspective, a perfectly sensible thing to do. For the defined benefit, the big occupational pension schemes that are winding down now, 30 years ago, they had huge amounts invested in UK equities. They now have almost nothing invested in UK equities. Now that's partly because of the regulatory system and partly because of the fact that they are in rundown.

[00:25:17] They've got nearly all of their money in gilts. So there is something to be said for having bigger funds here because the bigger they are, the more they can diversify into things like private equity and venture capital and they can take a bit more risk and be a bit more active. And so you're right to a degree that the scale of Australian pension funds leaves them able to be more active. But they're also investing huge amounts in the UK at the moment.

[00:25:46] But they have only just surpassed the point where it's 50-50. So it's almost half is still invested domestically. But I mean, the point it's trying to make, because it sort of says something, doesn't it? If we're not investing enough within the country, because the only way you're going to get out of the mesh, surely, other than having low interest rates, so you've got a lower cost of debt, is through productivity gains. And for that, it's hard to get productivity gains without investment in the technology which is going to deliver those productivity gains.

[00:26:14] So you need that investment to come from somewhere. And if we're saying, well, investors are looking, you know, what money there is, investors are looking overseas rather than domestically, that points to part of the problem that people are going, well, we're not going to get the returns if we invest in the UK. Then that's the fundamental issue, isn't it? Well, that's why this government and the last government has been pressurising pensions, really quite heavily pressurising them to invest more in the UK and in particular in unlisted equities and in infrastructure kinds of investments.

[00:26:44] And they've got a lot of pushback from the industry. Say, look, our job is to make the best return we can for our investors. And, you know, there is good reason to think that the best way of doing that is to put your money into a global tracker. It's very cheap and it diversifies your risk around the world. Now, one of the arguments for bringing pension funds together and consolidating them and having them bigger is that it allows them to spread the cost

[00:27:14] of more difficult or more expensive ways of investing much more evenly. So broadly speaking, I agree with you that having bigger funds is probably going to be somewhat better for the level of investment in the UK. But one of the issues is it's really, really hard as a consumer. You know, don't forget in the end, these pension funds belong to individuals who want the best pension they can get. You don't know. I don't know.

[00:27:44] I haven't got the first clue, actually, what is going to be the best place for me to put my pension. I can see how much it costs to invest this. Other things equal. I put it into something that doesn't cost very much. And that means probably something which is reasonably passive. It's probably in some kind of track of funds. So there's a sort of, there is a, there's a real divergence between the information, the risk, the role of pensions in providing money

[00:28:13] for individuals and their potential role for helping the economy as a whole. I don't like the idea of the government telling my pension provider where it should put its money. I think that way lies really, you know. Well, they did. Of course, they've stepped it up domestically for HS2, haven't they? So you have to, you have to put a proportion. So I mean, maybe they should have gone further on that. But Paul, this thing we're coming back to, I mean, the detail about pensions, investments,

[00:28:42] all matters. But overall, this picture that we have of a doom loop that we are paying vast amounts in interest on rising debt, that the economy has got to the point where we don't have a rise in living standards if anything, a decline, it seems like potentially. Is there any way that this can be, I mean, we talked about tinkering to do with change in regulation, everything else, but this still doesn't seem to be the answer. We don't have growth. We don't have the prospect of rising incomes. So are we simply going

[00:29:12] further and further down? Is that how it's going to happen? Well, of course, don't forget, I mean, part of the reason that there's been such a bad decade is we've had COVID, we've had an energy prices have gone up enormously. Now, those are genuinely outside of our control and hopefully those won't be repeated. And there are things that hopefully will help. I mean, I think there is increasing evidence that the rollout of AI will always somewhat at least increase in productivity, which should lead

[00:29:42] to some gains. But to repeat my point, I mean, there are things government can do which will be good for the long-term living standards in this country, whether that is tax reform, whether it's reforming the regulations around infrastructure, whether it's doing something sensible around our housing market, whether it's, as we were discussing, making changes to the welfare system.

[00:30:10] It's about having credible fiscal policies, giving companies certainty. I mean, there are, I mean, genuinely things that we know that will be effective, but they take time to come to fruition. And in a world, and this is the problem, this is the sort of political doom loop we're potentially in, which is that when incomes aren't going up, it's very difficult for governments to get the time and the space to make these long-term reforms, which don't help you in, you know, years one, two, and three,

[00:30:39] but which further down the road have the potential to have a really big and positive impact. I mean, all of that said, I mean, in the end, a lot of growth comes from, obviously, just the degree to which people are entrepreneurial, the degree to which the world economy is doing better. So you can certainly imagine a world in which the government just kind of carries on as it is, energy prices go down, the world economy picks up, technical change

[00:31:08] results in productivity improvements, and living standards start to pick up. You can certainly make that a lot easier if you make some of the changes and reforms that we've touched on. And what about, you mentioned AI and how that might increase productivity, because a lot of the, I mean, you'd hope it would, but at the moment, most of it is just making money for the providers of the AI technology, which are largely in Silicon Valley. And even if we do get productivity gains, we're not going to get any competitive edge

[00:31:37] against any other country in that, unless we can find a way that we... Well, two things on that. I think that's wrong on both counts. Good. I mean, in a sense, it doesn't matter whether we get an edge against other countries in terms of the rollout of AI. If that just improves our productivity, that will make us better off. And, you know, and there is some evidence that that is beginning to happen, at least on a small scale. And secondly, actually, we do have, I mean, we clearly don't have competitive advantage

[00:32:07] against the US, but relative to most other countries, because, I mean, we are number three in the world. I mean, we're miles behind the US and China, but, you know, we're ahead of other countries in AI, technology development, rollout, venture capital, and all those sorts of things. So, I don't agree with either of your sort of premises in that question. But what about the job losses of that? I mean, we're talking about problems with household incomes. If there are not jobs for the people who have expected jobs,

[00:32:36] perhaps in lesser skilled occupations, let's put it in those terms, that's going to take a great tranche out of people's everyday incomes, isn't it? That's almost inevitable. And push up their welfare bill. Possibly. I don't know the answer to that, and I don't think anyone knows the answer to that. And if you look at all previous technological changes, they have had that, the effect that you describe in the short run, and then in the long run, they have been positive for both jobs and earnings. Now, the other thing

[00:33:06] about previous technological changes is you're right, they have tended to take jobs from the lower skilled. It's not obvious that that's true of AI. Certainly, it's more likely to kind of push up into the sort of higher skilled white collar, maybe higher skilled isn't the right word, but more up into the white collar professions than has been the case previously. The real question for AI is, is this going to be fundamentally different in kind to previous technologies in that it does

[00:33:36] so much that there's really nothing left for the rest of us to do? And I don't think anyone knows the answer to that. I mean, I am broadly speaking an optimist on this, partly just because we know that every other technology throughout history has not led in the long run to a reduction in jobs. The thing that does worry me is the adjustment that is happening in a lot of firms who are, for example, not taking on so many graduates as they used to do. And, you know,

[00:34:05] that could result in a generation who are really struggling and indeed may be a problem for those firms later on when there aren't enough people with the experience and skills to take things through. So there is some evidence, particularly in that young graduate labour market, which does worry. Were there some quick wins that could have been done that haven't been done by this government or any previous governments? Well, I don't think there are quick wins. I mean, that's part of the problem. And there are definitely wins. You know, we should abolish

[00:34:35] stamp duty on housing for sure. I mean, that's disastrous. But actually, chances keep on increasing it. We can do some of the things. Replace it with a land tax, for example? Well, replace it with certainly a more sensible version of council tax, which applies to the actual value of a house and isn't regressive in the value of the house 35 years ago. So there are reforms that you could do to property taxation. We've talked about some of the changes to regulation. I mean, here's an example, and

[00:35:04] people may disagree with me about this, but I think it's a really important one. So when Keir Starmer left office, he said there were three things that he was really proud of. Three things. And one of them was Martin's law. Martin's law is this big additional slew of regulation which has been placed on anywhere that hosts events. And it follows the massacre arena bombing, and it creates, for church halls and Oxford

[00:35:32] colleges and clubs and all sorts of other places, it creates an enormous additional regulatory burden to almost no positive effect. But I think that is the problem of politics. I mean, if the prime minister says that's the thing he's proudest of, and it's something which is costly and ineffective, because it sounds like he's doing something. Here is a problem. Here is something that terrible has happened, so we have to do something about it, so we'll add another regulation.

[00:36:01] We see the same thing in the response to the Grenfell disaster. I mean, of course that was a disaster. But the response has been to put in a whole new regulatory authority and to ban tall buildings without additional staircases, even though the government's own cost-benefit analysis suggests that this will be massively expensive relative to any possible benefit. And the result? We just simply stop building tall buildings because they're too expensive to do.

[00:36:30] So these are just little examples in a way of why we end up in the problem of the red industry. Can I ask you another little example? Earning $100,000 used to be a lot of money, and now it's like a middle income almost, isn't it, in the UK? And yet, when you get to that level, you lose your personal allowance, which will be an incentive for you to say, well, okay, I'm not going to take that extra money. I'm going to put more into my pension, for example, which is a good thing that

[00:37:00] you're putting more into your pension, but it also means that you're not spending that money in the economy today. So that cliff where you're paying, you know, you're ending up paying 60% tax in effect, which is uncomfortable for most people when you hit that level, and also the tax thresholds, which obviously have been reducing the real income for people. I mean, getting those structures sorted out so there's an incentive for you to keep on earning and going up to the next bracket and keep on earning and spending more in the economy is a problem, isn't it? Because it seems

[00:37:30] to be prohibitive at the moment. And it's really important, I mean, just in terms of context, I mean, about 20, 25 years ago, we had 2 or 3 million people paying higher rate tax, that's the 40% tax. We've now got 2 or 3 million people paying 60% or 45%, so with earnings over £100,000. So this is still obviously the better off group of the population, but it's a very fast-growing group.

[00:37:59] And it's worse even than you've described, because if you've got children, then you lose all right to free childcare at the point at which you hit £100,000, and you might have to earn another £30,000 or £40,000 before you stop being worse off. So that gives you a very big incentive just to stop going up at that. But yes, the numbers affected by the 60% and the 45% rate have risen really dramatically. And actually, one of the consequences of that is if you

[00:38:29] look at this increased tax burden over the last decade or so, a very high fraction of that, you might think this is the right thing to do, but it's important to understand it, a very high fraction of that is paid by high earners. And if you look over sort of a 15-year period, our tax burden has increased really quite dramatically on high earners and hasn't really increased on average earners. And of course, again, you can see the politics of that, but it's not obvious that that fits with the economic level.

[00:38:58] Those people are going from the average level to that high level around that 100 grand. And I know so many people who've done exactly this, they just say, right, well, I'm just going to sallow sacrifice and so I avoid paying the tax and so I can put it more into my pension. Yeah, and of course, it's a very worthwhile thing to do at that point because you get 60% tax. As we draw this to a conclusion, Paul, I mean, do you detect any kind of move from the Burnham government, as opposed to the Starmer government, in the right direction of the kind of things you're talking about, or do you think there is no way out of this, it's not going to

[00:39:28] happen, there's too much politics to let the things you're talking about happen? I don't know. Clearly the budget was a sort of standstill event, but I think that was deliberate because I think there is some sort of longer term planning going on behind the scenes. I think we're expecting at some point to see something that looks a bit like a 10-year plan. And to end on a sort of very somewhat political note, everything I've seen suggests to me that we're going to get a relatively early election.

[00:39:58] So there's two or three reasons for that. First, if you listen to everything that Andy Burnham says, and particularly you look at his conference speech back in October, it was all about the next parliament. I mean, he said nothing really about what he wants to do in the next two and a half years. I've got no idea what he wants to do in the next two and a half years. I've got a pretty good idea of some of the big things he wants to do after the next election. Secondly, if you look at the budget, it sets itself up for some really, really

[00:40:27] difficult choices at the spending review, which is supposed to happen next year. Now, if the economy really picks up and it looks a lot easier than it does now, then maybe we'll get through to that spending review in this parliament. If things don't start to look easier, I think they might decide it's easier to go ahead with an election before that. And then thirdly, of course, the opinion polls are moving in the right direction. I think there are lots of things pointing to an earlier rather than a later election. And then, and I suspect only then, will we really begin to see what

[00:40:57] this government actually wants to do. So, Paul, thank you very much indeed for that. Interesting ending on a political note. Well, we'll hold you to your thoughts, maybe talk to you next year and see if an election is immediately in prospect at that point. All right. Thanks, Paul. Cheers. Thank you. I guess the thing that could change, of course, is that we could see wars ending and oil prices come down and then inflation comes down and that might help as well. Well, we might, but on the other hand, an emboldened Trump, or perhaps a Trump that just doesn't care anymore

[00:41:27] after the midterms, which we suspect are not going to be great for him, might just say, oh, sod it, I'll bomb again. Who knows? Who knows? Yeah. But anyway, that's what we're going to be looking at, of course, next week. Yeah, how far can he go exactly if he's not got the mandate but he still has that ability to sign executive orders? How far can he go? And will he get challenged as well? Will proceedings against him start to happen as well? It's going to be an interesting time in America, isn't it, over the next few months, I think. We'll be looking at the new shape of Congress and what

[00:41:56] it means for America and the rest of us, which is the point, I guess. And that's all coming up next week. On The Why, Kev. We'll see you then. Thanks for joining us. The Why. Curve.